Bio-Polyamides: Where Do They Come From?

by Jeffrey Gotro on May 6, 2013

Guest Blog by Dr. Robert Humphreys

Rilsan connectors ArkemaBio-polyamides have been available commercially since the first half of the 20th Century, when Rilsan®11 was first introduced1. Image at left are Rilsan®HT connectors (source: Arkema).  Since then, other partly or fully bio-sourced polyamides have been commercialized for a range of applications. Properties, formulation and applications of bio-polyamides have been reviewed in several recent, readily available publications2, so it might be valuable to focus instead on the technologies employed to produce the key bio-polyamide raw materials. The discussion will demonstrate how organic chemistry and catalysis can be critical to converting renewable raw materials into technologically valuable polymers.

Structures of the key raw materials for some partially or fully bio-sourced polyamides are shown in Figure 1. Both 11-aminoundecanoic acid and sebacic acid are products from chemical conversion of ricinoleic acid, the major fatty acid component of castor oil3.

Figure 1

Castor oil is hydrolyzed to give ricinoleic acid and glycerol, which are separated. High temperature treatment of the methyl ester of ricinoleic acid produces 11-undecanelic acid and heptanal4. Bromination of the double bond of 11-undecalenic acid followed by reaction with ammonia gives 11-aminoundecanoic acid, the monomer used to make PA 11 (Rilsan® 11). The overall process is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2

Sebacic acid is produced commercially by “fusing” ricinoleic acid with alkali (reacting at high temperature with sodium or potassium hydroxide). This chemistry has been known for decades and has been optimized significantly. The process generates 2-octanol and hydrogen gas as co-products (see Figure 3). This complicated reaction has been explained mechanistically5.

Figure 3

At present, there is no large-scale commercial source of bio-based 1,12-dodecanedioic acid, although potential routes have been reported6. Polyamides produced from this monomer rely on 1,12-dodecanedioic acid prepared from petroleum-derived butadiene 7 (see Figure 4), so such polymers are only partially bio-sourced, assuming that the diamine component is derived from renewable sources.

Figure 4

Polyamides based on diacids such as sebacic acid and 1,12-dodecanedioic acid require a diamine co-monomer such as those shown in Figure 1. Curiously, two of the diamines shown are naturally occurring, although they are very unpleasant products of the decomposition of dead, rotting animal flesh. Cadaverine, or pentamethylenediamine (also known as 1,5-diaminopentane) is an extremely foul smelling natural product that is produced by the enzyme-catalyzed decarboxylation of lysine, one of the amino acids found in proteins, during the decomposition process of dead flesh. Cadaver dogs can detect decomposition products of dead bodies, such as cadaverine at extremely low levels. The one-carbon smaller tetramethylenediamine (1,4-diaminopentane) is also a foul smelling decomposition product of the deceased, earning the name “putrecine”. Putrecine is produced biologically by decarboxylation of the amino acid ornithine (see Figure 5).

Cadaverine is not produced on a significant scale commercially, although PA510 has been prepared industrially8. Since lysine is manufactured on a large, commercial scale via fermentation of sugars, cadaverine production from lysine via lysine decarboxylase is a likely route to renewable cadaverine. On the other hand, tetramethylenediamine is produced commercially from succinonitrile, which in turn is made by addition of hydrogen cyanide to acrylonitrile. Similar chemistry is also employed to produce hexamethylenediamine, a compound with a strong fishy smell that is the characteristic odor of many organic amine compounds. Decamethylenediamine is produced commercially from ricinoleic acid, presumably via sebacic acid (see above).

Figure 5

PA 11 was developed well before renewability was fashionable, so it is reasonable to conclude that it was commercially successful because the properties of the polymer, such as impact strength, low moisture absorption and chemical resistance, have sufficient value in the market place. Similar benefits are offered by other, partially renewable polyamides shown in Figure 1; all of these polymers have the potential to be 100% renewable.

References:

1. “Application of Eco-profile Methodology to Polyamide 11”, Jean-Francois Devaux, Guillaume Le, Bernard Pees, click for reference

2. a) “Basics of Bio-polyamides”, Michael Thielen, Bioplastics Magazine, March 2010, 5, 50-53; b) “Bio-polyamides for Automotive Applications”, http://www.ibvt.de/_Downloads/Presse/bioplasticsmagazine.pdf ; c) “Polyamides from renewable sources as matricies of short fiber reinforced biocomposites”, Stanislaw Kuciel, Paulina Kuzniar, Aneta Liber-Knec, Polimery, 2012, 57, 627-634.

3. a) “Castor Oil: a vital industrial raw material”, D.S.Ogunniyi, Bioresource Technology, 2006, 97, 1086-1091; b) “Comprehensive Castor Oil Report: a report on castor oil and castor oil derivatives”, Updated November 2010, click for reference

4. “Refinery of the future: feedstock, processes, products”, Jean-Luc DuBois, http://www.eurobioref.org/Summer_School/poster%20&%20lecture/L02.pdf .

5. “On the mechanism and synthetic applications of the thermal and alkaline degradation of c-18 castor oil”, s. Ranganathan, Raaj Kumar, V. Maniktala, Tetrahedron,1984, 40, 1167-1178.

6. See, for example: “Biosynthesis of monomers for plastics from renewable oils”, Wenhua Lu, Jon E. Ness, Wenchun Xia, Xiaoyan Zhang, Jeremy Minshull, and Richard A. Gross, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2010, 132, 15451-15455. And references cited.

7. a) “Cyclotrimerization of butadiene using nickel catalyst”, US Patent 3,723,533, March 27, 1973; b) “Preparation of straight chain dicarboxylic acids”, US Patent 3,637,832, January 25, 1972.

8. See reference 2a, page 52.

{ 0 comments }

Syndiotactic_polypropenePolypropylene (PP) is a  thermoplastic polymer with a relatively high melting point (Tm=165C) and ability to process using injection molding.   The higher melting point of PP allows it to be used for plastic items such as medical products (withstand the heat in an autoclave) and dishwasher safe containers.  Additionally, polypropylene has good fatigue properties enabling use as plastic living hinges, such as those on flip-top bottles. Another application for polypropylene is as biaxially oriented polypropylene (BOPP) manufactured using a film blowing process.  BOPP sheets are used to make a wide variety of materials including clear bags. Biaxially oriented polypropylene is crystal clear and serves as an excellent packaging material for retail products.  Now let’s discuss some of the synthetic routes to bio-based polypropylene.

Synthetic Routes to Bio-PP

There are multiple pathways to obtain bio-based propylene, which is the starting monomer for PP.  We will not discuss the polymerization, since it is essentially the same once you have the propylene monomer.

A recent white paper (1) outlines the various bio-based synthetic routes to green propylene:

image

The two main routes are biochemical (typically fermentation) and thermochemical (involving gasification).  In either case, access to suitable feedstocks is critical to keep production costs in-line.  Typical bio-based feedstocks are corn, sugarcane, and beets. The biochemical route is being commercialized by the Brazilian chemical company Braskem who is the leader in the manufacturing of bio-polyethylene.  Braskem has access to large sugarcane crops in Brazil.  Enzymes are used in the fermentation process to convert sugars into ethanol and butene.  Metathesis of ethylene and butene produces propylene monomer.   The Braskem process can be summarized (2):

image

The thermochemical route employs a wide variety of bio-based feedstocks including grass, agricultural wastes and corn, which are carbon rich and can be gasified to produce syngas. Bio-diesel and vegatable oils can also be used in the production of green propylene.  The two routes are summarized below (1):

image

Production cost is a big driver.  The capital costs for the fermentation route are significantly lower compared with the gasification route.  The logical route for Braskem was to leverage their R&D and capital investment in the bio-PE plant to extend to the production of bio-PP.

It should be noted that once the propylene monomer is obtained, the existing polymerization technologies yield high molecular weight polypropylene with identical properties compared to fossil fuel based PP.  As many have stressed before, green PE and PP are bio-based, and like there fossil fuel counterparts, they are not biodegradable (or compostable).  The challenge for bio-PP producers is to develop process technology that can compete in the marketplace (near cost parity) with fossil fuel based polypropylene.

References

1) Virat Venkataraman, Propy-LENE Supply, Go Green, On Purpose Technologies for the Future, Beroe, Inc. (www.beroe-inc.com)

2) James Kahn, Green PE: The Value Proposition and Success in the Marketplace and Green PP: Update on Commercialization,  Bioplastics; The Reinention of Plastics Conference, March 6, 2013, Las Vegas, NV

{ 0 comments }

Aliphatic Poly(alkylenedicarboxylate) Polyesters: Organic or Not Organic?

April 15, 2013

Guest Post by Dr. Robert Humphreys I don’t buy “organic” foods except on the rare occasion that I can find them at price parity with the “not organic” version. I admit that organic vegetables and fruits tend to be more attractive in appearance, at least on the store shelf. People I know who are devotees [...]

Read the full article →

Polyethylene Furanoate (PEF): 100% Biobased Polymer to Compete with PET?

April 8, 2013

In our July 9, 2012 post we discussed the initiative driven by Coca Cola to develop bio-based plastics for beverage containers.  The first phase of this massive project has resulted in the Plant BottleTM which is made using bio-PET where the ethylene glycol starting monomer is made from renewable sources.  The Plant Bottle contains approximately [...]

Read the full article →

Polyhydroxyalkanoates: Nature’s Polyester

April 1, 2013

Guest Post by Dr. Robert Humphreys Whenever I think of polyester, I am reminded of an old Steve Martin joke directed at the tacky clothes worn by band member Tommy Newsom during the Tonight Show: “Do you know how many polyesters had to die to make that suit?” There is actually some truth to this [...]

Read the full article →

Bioplastics Conference Highlight; Push to Bio-based Durables Underway

March 25, 2013

At the recent Bioplastics: The Reinvention of Plastics conference in Las Vegas, March 4-6, 2013 there were 25 papers, 21 exhibitors, talking about their recent advances in biopolymers and bioplastics.  There was one consistent theme echoed over the last couple years.  Bioplastics are increasingly finding interesting applications in durables.  Initially, a lot of industry buzz [...]

Read the full article →

From Sugar to Bioplastics; Fermentation in Action

March 18, 2013

Guest Post by Dr. Robert Humphreys In the previous post, Dr. Gotro presented some amazing data on production of bio-ethylene (bio-E) and bio-polyethylene (bio-PE). It may come as a surprise to find that fermentation, the process that is used to make beer, wine, yogurt and cheese, is also the source of bio-ethylene that is polymerized [...]

Read the full article →

Bio Polyethylene: Drop-in Replacement

March 11, 2013

At a the recent Bioplastics: The Re-invention of Plastics conference, James Kahn of Braskem gave a good update on the current state of bio-based polyethylene.  Braskem is the world leading supplier of bio-PE.  In 2010 and the forecast for 2015, bio-PE is the largest bio-based polymer currently in production.  So let’s take a deeper look [...]

Read the full article →

Thermoplastic Starch: A Renewable, Biodegradable Bioplastic

March 4, 2013

Guest Blog by Dr. Robert Humphreys Crops that are high in starch are the principal source of food calories for people globally, although many affluent people tend to think of starch as a thickener for sauces and gravies or as “bad carbs” in a health conscious diet. On the other hand, even technologically savvy people [...]

Read the full article →

Bioplastics: An Industry Poised for Growth

February 25, 2013

By far some of our most popular posts have covered the exciting new field of biopolymers and bioplastics.  The image on the left shows a smartphone cover made from Ingeo polylactic acid (PLA) from NatureWorks.  In a fairly extensive set of posts, Dr. Bob Humphreys and I will cover a wide variety of biopolymers currently [...]

Read the full article →