Polymer Innovation Blog

Practical tips and advice for polymer, innovation and product development professionals

Polymer Innovation
  • Home
  • eBooks
    • Polymers in Electronic Packaging
    • Rheology of Thermosets eBook
    • Practical Tips for Curing Thermosets
    • Thermoset Characterization
    • Dielectric Cure Monitoring of Thermosets
    • Introduction to Biopolymers and Bioplastics
  • Videos
    • Core Curriculum: 3 Part Video Series
    • Characterization of Thermosets: 4 Part Video Series
    • Advanced Thermoset Cure Kinetics: 3 Part Video Series
    • DSC of Polymers: 5 Part Video Series
    • Thermoplastics: 5 Part Video Series
  • Services
    • Consulting
    • Polymer Expert Witness
  • Learning Center
    • White Paper
  • Why Jeff?
    • Speaker Info
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Members
    • Login
    • Logout

Featured Article

Measuring the Toughness of Thermosets

October 2, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest post by Jeremy Pasatta, Advanced Polymer Coatings

Now that we have looked at the theory of toughening thermosets with second phase tougheners along with the two most common tougheners (RLP and coreshell particles) let’s look at how we measure the toughness of thermosets.  There are several different methods to measure the toughness of thermosets, and the method that is chosen often depends on the type of thermoset, the application, and exactly how the thermoset is being used withing the application.  Table 1 gives an overview of the different ways of measuring thermoset toughness for different applications along with the ASTM or ISO standard method.

Table 1.  Methods for Measuring Toughness of Thermosets

 

Fracture toughness can be measured in different modes including tensile fracture, shear fracture and tearing fractures, but for thermosets the most common mode is Mode 1, or tensile fracture, because this is often how most thermosets will fail and a convenient method for measuring samples in the lab. An overview of the different modes is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1. Fracture Toughness Modes (from ref [1])

The two most common units for representing the fracture toughness of a neat thermoset are K1C and G1C, which are the plain strain fracture toughness and the fracture energy respectively.  Typically, a rectangular specimen of neat thermoset is machined with a notch and two holes for loading into a Universal Tester.  In the machined notch, a crack is usually initiated with a nitrogen cooled razor blade, and the sample is pulled apart under Mode I at a defined rate with the energy required to maintain stable crack growth measured.  A typical example of machined neat thermoset for fracture toughness is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Typical Neat Thermoset Fracture Toughness Specimens (from ref [2])

A study was conducted comparing coreshell resins to CTBN on their effectiveness to toughen a standard bisphenol A epoxy cured with methylhexhydropthalic anhydride [3]. The coreshell resins tested are summarized in Table 2. The CTBN used as comparison is listed in Table 3 and was a standard CTBN containing 18% acrylonitrile.

Table 2.  Coreshell Resins Tested for Toughening

K1C and G1C were determined using ISO 13586 with single-edge notch bend (SENB) specimens and the results are given in Table 3 at a comparative loading of 9% toughener.

Table 3.  Kc and Gc Results for Coreshell and CTBN Tougheners

The data in Table 3 indicates that at a 9% loading level, the toughened samples with CTBN (at 18% acrylonitrile) achieved the highest K1C and G1C values, although the CTBN it did depress the Tg more than the coreshell samples.  As noted in previous blog posts, a CTBN that does not phase separate will remain dissolved in the matrix resin and depress the Tg.  This study does show how much coreshell and CTBN tougheners can improve the fracture toughness and additionally presents a model for the fracture toughness behavior of the coreshell resins.

The speed at which fracture toughness is tested can also have different effects for different tougheners.  Automotive structural adhesives typically need to withstand impact at high rates of speed, which is why the impact wedge peel test, ISO 11343 was developed.  In this test, typically done at temperatures as low as -40˚C, a wedge is drawn through two adherends at high rate of speed.  For this type of high impact event, CTBN often is not enough to toughen because the particle cavitation will not be able to respond to the rate of testing, and other tougheners such as phenol terminated polyurethanes are used.  A comparison of the structure of phenol terminated polyurethanes and CTBN is given in Figure 3.

Figure 3. Chemical Structure of Phenol Terminated Polyurethane and CTBN (from ref [4])

When tested at various concentrations, the phenol terminated polyurethane gave stable crack growth with a high energy to maintain that crack growth, while the CTBN gave a brittle fracture.  It should be noted though that the phenol terminated polyurethane significantly decreased the Tg of the epoxy system, more so than the CTBN, and also greatly increased the viscosity of the system.  Figure 4 shows not only the set-up of the impact wedge peel test but also the difference in the brittle fracture of the CTBN modified sample versus the stable crack growth of the phenol terminated polyurethane sample.

Figure 4. Impact Wedge Peel Testing of CTBN vs. Phenol Terminated PU (from ref [4])

Now that we have looked at the need for tougheners, the two most common tougheners, RLP and coreshell, along with some common methods for measuring toughness and typical results, the next set of blog posts will cover some of the less commonly used types of tougheners along with some current topics and challenges with thermoset toughening.

References

  1. Rocha-Rangel, Enrique. ‘Fracture Toughness Determinations by Means of Indentation Fracture’. Nanocomposites with Unique Properties and Applications in Medicine and Industry, InTech, 23 Aug. 2011. Crossref, doi:10.5772/18127.
  2. Bajpai, Ankur & Martin, R. & Faria, H & Ibarboure, E. & Carlotti, Stephane. (2020). Epoxy based hybrid nanocomposites: Fracture mechanisms, tensile properties and electrical properties. Materials today: proceedings. 10.1016/j.matpr.2020.02.797.
  3. Giannakopoulos, G. & Masania, Kunal & Taylor, Ambrose. (2011). Toughening of epoxy using core–shell particles. Journal of Materials Science – J MATER SCI. 46. 327-338. 10.1007/s10853-010-4816-6.
  4. Polymers2020, 12(7), 1549; https://doi.org/10.3390/polym12071549
Share on LinkedIn Share

More From the Blog

Toughening Thermosets with Coreshell Particles

September 18, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest post by Jeremy Pasatta, Advanced Polymer Coatings The previous two blog posts have looked at both the fundamentals of toughening thermosets as well as one of the most common technologies used to toughen thermosets – Reactive Liquid Polymers and CTBN.  In this blog post, we’ll look at ... [Click to Continue...]

Professional Development Course at IMAPS-San Diego

September 12, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

Join me at the IMAPS International Symposium on Microelectronics in October. I will be presenting a Professional Development Course on: Polymers for Wafer Level Packaging Monday, October 2 at 10:30 AM. Course Description The course has been completely updated to include a detailed discussion ... [Click to Continue...]

Toughening Thermosets with Reactive Liquid Polymers

September 5, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest post by Jeremy Pasatta, Advanced Polymer Coatings In the previous blog post, we explored the reasons why thermosets benefit from the addition of second phase tougheners.  One of the most successful and widely used forms of second phase tougheners is Reactive Liquid Polymers, or RLP.  RLP can ... [Click to Continue...]

The Need for Tougheners in Thermosets

August 21, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest post by Jeremy Pasatta, Advanced Polymer Coatings Thermosets such as epoxies, vinyl esters, cyanate esters, and benzoxazines give excellent properties such as chemical and thermal resistance, dimensional stability, high modulus and good adhesion to a variety of substrates.  These properties ... [Click to Continue...]

Beyond Epoxy: High Performance Thermosets Part Six – Cyanate Esters for Electronic Packaging Applications

June 12, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

This is the final post in this series on high performance thermosetting polymers.  This post discussed the use of specialized cyanate esters for high performance electronic packaging applications. Dicyanate resins are versatile thermosets and have been used in a wide variety of applications. For ... [Click to Continue...]

Beyond Epoxy: High Performance Thermosets Part Five, Electronic Packaging

May 30, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

The previous post covered an introduction to cyanate ester thermosetting resins. This post will discuss the main applications of cyanate ester thermosets.  In the 1980’s the main applications for cyanate esters were in electronic applications. Specifically, cyanate esters were used in high ... [Click to Continue...]

Beyond Epoxy: High Performance Thermosets Part Four – Cyanate Esters

May 15, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

The previous posts in this series covered various types of bismaleimide resins and formulations.  The next three posts will discuss cyanate ester resins and formulated products. Dicyanate resins, alternatively known as cyanate ester resins, describes both a family of monomers and oligomers with ... [Click to Continue...]

Beyond Epoxy: High Performance Thermosets Part Three – Liquid Bismaleimides

May 1, 2023 By Jeffrey Gotro

The previous two posts covered aromatic BMI resins and curing mechanisms leading to highly crosslinked and high Tg thermosets.  Another important class of bismaleimides are liquid bismaleimides.   Liquid BMIs with long-chain aliphatic structures between the maleimide groups are used for low modulus, ... [Click to Continue...]

Polymer Innovation Blog

I’m Dr. Jeff Gotro and welcome to the Polymer Innovation Blog. Over the last 40 years I have been involved in polymer research, along with product and process development. I acquired invaluable experience working for IBM, AlliedSignal, Honeywell and Ablestik Labs (now Henkel). In this blog, I (along with some guest contributors) will share our experiences, tips, and “tricks of the trade” to get more out of your innovation efforts and discuss new trends and technical advances in the polymer industry.
View Jeff Gotro, Ph.D., CMC's profile on LinkedIn

Innocentrix, LLC


Click to Visit Website

plastics expert witness
Click for More Information

Subscribe by Email

Search the Blog

Polymer Video Training

Visit our Video Store

Polymers in Electronic Packaging

polymers in electronic packaging Are you confused about what is electronic packaging? Have you ever wondered what type of polymers and polymer-based composites are used in electronics? Learn More...

Practical Tips for Curing Thermosets

practical tips for curing thermosets Have you ever had a question about the degree of cure or is your part fully cured after processing? Confused about what is gelation or how does vitrification impact thermoset curing? Learn More...

Rheology of Thermosets

rheology of thermosets Have you ever had a question about measuring the rheological properties of thermosets Didn’t know what is the right experimental approach to get the right rheological information? Learn More...

Dielectric Cure Monitoring of Thermosets

Dielectric Cure Monitoring of Thermosets Do you have a need for an in-situ cure monitor for a thermoset process but don’t know where to start? Are you confused about the terminology used in dielectric spectroscopy? Learn More...

Introduction to Biopolymers and Bioplastics

Introduction to Biopolymers and Bioplastics Would you like to know how sustainable are bio-based polymers? Or what is the market size and growth rate for bioplastics? Or have questions about the biomass supply chain? Learn More...

Thermoset Characterization

Thermoset Characterization Have you ever had a question about how to measure a physical property of a thermoset? Confused about what is gelation or how does vitrification impact thermoset curing profiles? Or wondered how to measure the glass transition temperature of an epoxy or polyester composite? Learn More...

Amazon.com Bookshelf

Robert's Rules of Innovation Thermal Analysis of Polymers Order

Copyright © 2023 Innocentrix, LLC · All Rights Reserved**