Polymer Innovation Blog

Practical tips and advice for polymer, innovation and product development professionals

Polymer Innovation
  • Home
  • eBooks
    • Polymers in Electronic Packaging
    • Rheology of Thermosets eBook
    • Practical Tips for Curing Thermosets
    • Thermoset Characterization
    • Dielectric Cure Monitoring of Thermosets
    • Introduction to Biopolymers and Bioplastics
  • Videos
    • Core Curriculum: 3 Part Video Series
    • Characterization of Thermosets: 4 Part Video Series
    • Advanced Thermoset Cure Kinetics: 3 Part Video Series
    • DSC of Polymers: 5 Part Video Series
    • Thermoplastics: 5 Part Video Series
  • Services
    • Consulting
    • Polymer Expert Witness
  • Learning Center
    • White Paper
  • Why Jeff?
    • Speaker Info
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Members
    • Login
    • Logout

Featured Article

Dielectric Cure Monitoring Part Five: Choose the Optimum Frequency for Cure Monitoring

March 7, 2022 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest Post by Huan Lee, Lambient Technologies

The dielectric response of thermosets and resins depends on a number of factors that vary with frequency, so it is important to select an optimum frequency for dielectric cure monitoring (DEA). To inform this choice, we must look at the material property most directly related to cure state, which is frequency independent resistivity—also known as ion viscosity—defined as follows:

  • Frequency independent resistivity (ion viscosity) – thermoset resistivity that is constant or nearly constant across a range of AC frequencies and measured without a DC bias

Recent research confirms measurement without a DC bias is necessary to avoid electrochemical effects that confound the data. We will examine these phenomena in the next post.

Now let’s look at the example of PR 520N [Ref. 1], a pre-mixed epoxy system engineered for resin transfer molding (RTM). At room temperature PR 520N is a thick off-white paste and the manufacturer specifies full cure after two hours at 179 °C. For our test PR 520N was applied to a Mini-Varicon [Ref. 2] sensor like that shown in Figure 1, and an LT‑451 Dielectric Cure Monitor [Ref. 3] measured dielectric properties at multiple frequencies while the sample was heated to 180 °C.

Figure 1.  Mini-Varicon dielectric cure sensor

Figure 2 is a plot of the AC resistivity of PR 520N during isothermal cure at 180 °C. Although the data have both frequency independent and frequency dependent components, for convenience all are plotted against an axis labeled ion viscosity.

Figure 2.  AC resistivity of PR 520N during isothermal cure at 180 °C

Three features are apparent in Figure 2:

  • Distortion of 1 Hz curve during early cure, from 0 to 15 minutes, due to electrode polarization and the resulting boundary layer capacitance [Ref. 4]
  • Curves that overlap or nearly overlap, indicating the dominance of frequency independent resistivity
    • Caused by flow of mobile ions—true ion viscosity
    • Before gelation, change of frequency independent resistivity is often proportional to change of viscosity
    • After gelation, change of frequency independent resistivity is often proportional to change of modulus
  • Curves that diverge, indicating the dominance of frequency dependent resistivity
    • Caused by rotation of dipoles
    • For certain frequencies, does not correlate well with cure state

 

After cure analysis software removed the frequency dependent resistivity, only frequency independent resistivity remains, as shown in Figure 3. These data can now properly be called ion viscosity and accurately follow cure state for the entire test.

Figure 3.  Ion viscosity of PR 520N, with composite of frequencies, for cure of PR 520N at 180 °C

 The ion viscosity of Figure 3 is a composite of frequencies from 1 Hz to 1 kHz. Valuable information, such as the time of maximum reaction rate or the time to end of cure, is available from the slope of log(ion viscosity), often called slope for brevity. Unfortunately, the ion viscosity segments of Figure 3 do not overlap perfectly and would yield a confusing series of discontinuous curves for slope.

To avoid this problem, we can calculate slope from a single frequency; and, fortunately, the data from only one frequency is often sufficient. Indeed, we see from Figure 2 the 10 Hz data closely follows the overall composite ion viscosity and avoids the distortion caused by electrode polarization—in this case 10 Hz would be the optimum frequency for cure monitoring. The resulting ion viscosity and slope are plotted in Figure 4.

Figure 4.  Ion viscosity (green) and slope (blue) of PR 520N at 10 Hz, for cure of PR 520N at 180 °C

At about 120 minutes, the 10 Hz ion viscosity curve approaches a constant value and the slope approaches zero, indicating the reaction is slowing and cure is ending. This behavior agrees with the manufacturer’s specifications of full cure after two hours at 179 °C.

The higher frequency curves of Figure 2, however, follow only early cure and flatten significantly before 120 minutes—after various points, depending on frequency, they no longer correlate with cure state. In the extreme case, the 10 kHz curve incorrectly suggests cure ends after only 30 minutes!

With this understanding of ion viscosity and its correlation with cure state, we can make the following guidelines for frequency selection, adjusting for the slightly different goals and instrument capabilities of different applications:

Research and Development

  • Goal is accurate correlation of ion viscosity with cure
  • Instruments for R&D usually can measure with multiple frequencies and have a wide frequency range
  • If cure time permits, measure with multiple frequencies (e.g. 1 Hz, 10 Hz, 100 Hz, 1 kHz, 10 kHz) for best overview about material behavior and optimum frequency
  • If possible, use boundary layer correction [Ref. 4] to fix distortion caused by electrode polarization
  • Use the lowest practical frequency that avoids distortion caused by electrode polarization

Quality Assurance/Quality Control or Manufacturing

  • Goal is repeatable correlation of ion viscosity or AC resistivity with cure
  • Instruments for QA/QC or manufacturing usually measure with a single frequency and have a limited frequency range
  • Use the lowest practical frequency that avoids distortion caused by electrode polarization

Do you have a new material to test and don’t know where to start? Try 10 Hz or 100 Hz. Interestingly, these two frequencies are optimum for the cure monitoring of the majority of thermosets and composites—especially widely used materials like sheet molding compound (SMC), bulk molding compound (BMC), epoxy molding compound (EMC), prepregs and UV-cured resins.

Occasionally, a material with very low conductivity would need 1 Hz; and infrequently a very conductive material would need 1 kHz or higher. So start with 10 Hz or 100 Hz and choose a higher or lower frequency based on your results.

References

  1. Cycom PR 520N RTM manufactured by Solvay, Brussels, Belgium
  2. Mini-Varicon sensor, manufactured by Lambient Technologies, Cambridge, MA USA. https://lambient.com
  3. LT-451 Dielectric Cure Monitor, manufactured by Lambient Technologies, Cambridge, MA USA
  4. D.R. Day, J. Lewis, H.L Lee, S.D. Senturia, “The Role of Boundary Layer Capacitance at Blocking Electrodes in the Interpretation of Dielectric Cure Data in Adhesives,” Journal of Adhesion, 1985, vol.18, p.73.

Share on LinkedIn Share

More From the Blog

Dielectric Cure Monitoring Part Four: Use Log Scales to Get the Most from Ion Viscosity

February 21, 2022 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest Post by Huan Lee, Lambient Technologies Instead of ion viscosity (electrical resistivity), many users of older cure monitoring equipment measure a material’s conductance and plot the results on a linear scale. Why conductance? Why a linear scale? Because that is an old-school method based on ... [Click to Continue...]

Dielectric Cure Monitoring Part Three: Real-Time Monitoring of a UV Cured Resin

February 7, 2022 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest Post by Huan Lee, Lambient Technologies One advantage of dielectric cure monitoring (DEA) is the ability to observe rapid polymerization of UV curable adhesives like H.B. Fuller U3345, [Ref. 1] the topic of this post. In this case the use of techniques such as DSC is not possible, or at least ... [Click to Continue...]

Dielectric Cure Monitoring Part Two: Cure Monitoring of Epoxy Molding Compound (Part 2)

January 24, 2022 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest Post by Huan Lee, Lambient Technologies In the first post of this series, we saw in theory how ion viscosity changes as a thermoset cures, and how Critical Points can characterize the cure. Now let’s see how epoxy molding compound cures in reality. Samples of EMC were placed on a Lambient ... [Click to Continue...]

Dielectric Cure Monitoring Part One: Cure Monitoring of Epoxy Molding Compound (Part 1)

January 10, 2022 By Jeffrey Gotro

Guest Post by Huan Lee, Lambient Technologies Normally available in either B-staged powders or pellets for transfer molding, epoxy molding compound (EMC) is essential for electronics packaging and is used to encapsulate billions of integrated circuits each year. Figure 1. Granular (left) and ... [Click to Continue...]

Happy New Year

January 1, 2022 By Jeffrey Gotro

Happy New Year and Best Wishes for a Safe and Prosperous 2022! ... [Click to Continue...]

Happy Holidays

December 20, 2021 By Jeffrey Gotro

  It's that time of the year for the Chemistree! Happy Holidays and Best Wishes for a Prosperous 2022! ... [Click to Continue...]

Welcome to Polymer Innovation Blog

October 18, 2021 By Jeffrey Gotro

Thank you for stopping by to visit my blog on polymers, plastics and innovation. I am in the process of developing new content.  I will be blogging on product development, new advances in polymers, recycling/re-use and more. Please use the search feature on the right to look for content that may ... [Click to Continue...]

Happy Fourth of July

July 2, 2021 By Jeffrey Gotro

              Happy Fourth of July for all my readers.  Enjoy the long weekend with friends and family. ... [Click to Continue...]

Polymer Innovation Blog

I’m Jeff Gotro and welcome to the Polymer Innovation Blog. Over the last 30 years I have been involved in polymers, innovation, along with product and process development. I acquired invaluable experience working for IBM, AlliedSignal, Honeywell and Ablestik Labs (now Henkel). In this blog, I will share some of my experiences, tips, and “tricks of the trade” to get more out of your innovation efforts and discuss new trends and technical advances in the polymer industry.
View Jeff Gotro, Ph.D., CMC's profile on LinkedIn

Innocentrix, LLC


Click to Visit Website

plastics expert witness
Click for More Information

Subscribe by Email

Search the Blog

Polymer Video Training

Visit our Video Store

Polymers in Electronic Packaging

polymers in electronic packaging Are you confused about what is electronic packaging? Have you ever wondered what type of polymers and polymer-based composites are used in electronics? Learn More...

Practical Tips for Curing Thermosets

practical tips for curing thermosets Have you ever had a question about the degree of cure or is your part fully cured after processing? Confused about what is gelation or how does vitrification impact thermoset curing? Learn More...

Rheology of Thermosets

rheology of thermosets Have you ever had a question about measuring the rheological properties of thermosets Didn’t know what is the right experimental approach to get the right rheological information? Learn More...

Dielectric Cure Monitoring of Thermosets

Dielectric Cure Monitoring of Thermosets Do you have a need for an in-situ cure monitor for a thermoset process but don’t know where to start? Are you confused about the terminology used in dielectric spectroscopy? Learn More...

Introduction to Biopolymers and Bioplastics

Introduction to Biopolymers and Bioplastics Would you like to know how sustainable are bio-based polymers? Or what is the market size and growth rate for bioplastics? Or have questions about the biomass supply chain? Learn More...

Thermoset Characterization

Thermoset Characterization Have you ever had a question about how to measure a physical property of a thermoset? Confused about what is gelation or how does vitrification impact thermoset curing profiles? Or wondered how to measure the glass transition temperature of an epoxy or polyester composite? Learn More...

Amazon.com Bookshelf

Robert's Rules of Innovation Thermal Analysis of Polymers Order

Copyright © 2022 Innocentrix, LLC · All Rights Reserved**